What is VIN fraud and how do you avoid it?

What is VIN fraud?

VIN fraud is an automotive crime where someone steals the VIN from one vehicle to disguise another vehicle’s identity.

The VIN is a unique 17-character code assigned to every vehicle by its manufacturer. Theoretically, no two vehicles share the same VIN, but when criminals are involved, some clearly do.

The goal with this scam is to disguise a salvaged or stolen vehicle as a legitimate, clean-titled one. With a counterfeit VIN, scammers can sell the fraudulent car to unsuspecting buyers.

There’s practically no way for anyone to sell these vehicles with their original VIN, for obvious reasons:

• Stolen cars are flagged in police databases nationwide. They can’t be registered, insured, or sold under their real identity.
• Cars with a salvage or rebuilt title are either uninsurable or expensive to insure. Without insurance, a car can’t be registered or legally driven.

According to CARFAX Canada’s estimates, there are 372,000 vehicles nationwide with compromised VINs. Roughly 127,000 of those are Ontario-registered vehicles.²

How does VIN fraud work?

A reVINning scam usually involves two vehicles — a donor and a recipient.

• The donor is a legitimate, registered vehicle.
• The recipient is the stolen or salvage-repaired car the criminal wants to sell, often one of the same make, model, and year as the donor.

To pull off the scam, the donor’s VIN is copied and applied to the recipient vehicle.

There are several tactics a thief can use to retrieve the donor car’s VIN:

• They can photograph the VIN plate through the windshield without ever touching the car.
• They can source it directly from online listings, where dashboard photos or listing details frequently reveal the VIN.
• They can target vehicles registered in another province or country. With a foreign car’s VIN, duplicate records are less likely to surface in jurisdictional databases.

With the donor VIN secured, the criminal then fabricates a legitimate-looking VIN plate and installs it on the recipient vehicle, removing the original in the process. In more sophisticated operations, they may even reprogram the vehicle’s internal electronic control units (ECUs) to match the new VIN.

Parked cars are among the easiest targets — not just for VIN theft, but also other crimes, such as catalytic converter theft.

As for what’s fuelling the VIN cloning epidemic, it’s partly because targeting one crime has led to another.

The federal government has been cracking down on its ports, where stolen cars were routinely smuggled overseas. This means the criminals must find other ways to profit. One way is to sell them domestically instead, which reVINning facilitates.³

Of course, reVINned cars aren’t going to sail through provincial registries on fake paperwork, at least not without some inside help.

Alberta and Ontario are hotspots for this brand of corruption, driven by corrupt employees embedded within car registries and dealerships in those provinces.⁴ The bad actors create fictitious agreements using clean VINs and manipulate vehicle history reports to reflect the donor vehicle’s information.⁵ With that, they can register the disguised car in official systems, which is often enough to fool unsuspecting customers.

Related articles

• What’s the best anti-theft device for your car?
• How to protect your vehicle from theft

How to spot VIN fraud

There are steps you can take to protect yourself from buying a reVINned car.

• Inspect every VIN-marked spot. On most cars, the VIN appears in several places. Check the windshield (on the lower, driver’s side corner), the driver’s-side door jamb, and (on some older cars) the engine block. The same number should show in every location.
• Cross-reference the VIN against ownership documents. The VIN on the vehicle must exactly match the one on the registration and ownership papers exactly. Verify that the car’s make, model, year, and color match what’s on the paperwork. Any discrepancy, however minor, should warrant further investigation.
• Run a vehicle history report. CARFAX Canada has a VIN fraud check tool. It’s worth using on any used car you want to buy, even if you’re buying from a dealership. The tool scans billions of records and flags suspicious patterns that may be overlooked during a standard history report check. It’ll tell you if the car has an unusual registration history, missing import or export records, or if it has been reported stolen. If the search returns no results, or results that don’t match the car in front of you, be wary.
• Get a pre-purchase inspection. Before buying a used car, have it inspected by an independent mechanic, ideally one with no connection to the seller. Beyond assessing the car’s mechanical condition, a trained eye can catch signs of VIN tampering that aren’t obvious to the average buyer. The inspection might also turn up evidence of previous damage or repairs that weren’t disclosed, and in some cases, could potentially indicate the vehicle is actually a salvage vehicle.

Reporting VIN fraud

If you suspect a vehicle is reVINned, look at the steps below, depending on whether you’ve already bought the vehicle or not.

• If you haven’t purchased the vehicle yet, do not proceed with the transaction. Report it to your local police service. You can also file a report with the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (CAFC). If you found the listing on an online marketplace, like Kijiji or Facebook Marketplace, report it to the platform as well — it may still be live and targeting other buyers.
• If you’ve already purchased a reVINned vehicle, you may discover the fraud when you try to register the car. If so, contact your local police immediately. They’ll likely identify the car as stolen property, at which point they’ll need to seize it. The sooner you report the fraud, the less of a headache it’ll be. Notify your insurance provider as well, as they need to be made aware of the theft.

Insurance considerations

Like unsuspecting buyers, insurance companies can also be victimized by VIN fraud.

Some insurers don’t discover the fraud until they’ve already paid out on multiple claims, often on a vehicle worth far less than what they’ve covered it for.⁶ These payouts drive up settlement costs for those insurers, which results in a consequence every insurance customer dreads: increased premiums.

When a claim is filed, most insurers will pull a vehicle history report before proceeding. Sometimes, the discrepancies are obvious. These can include a car that changes color between service records, or one with registration history scattered across multiple provinces. If the insurer suspects VIN fraud, they’ll likely deny the claim.

As a consumer, the best way to avoid getting in this situation is to thoroughly research any used car before you buy it, including its claims history. Make sure the value of any past payouts is realistic for the car you’re looking at.

Commonly asked questions

What are the consequences of reVINning a car?

ReVINning a car is a criminal offence in Canada. Fraud of any deceptive nature involving property valued over $5,000 carries a maximum federal sentence of 14 years in prison.⁷ Many vehicles are obviously worth well above that $5,000 threshold, which means perpetrators face significant jail time if convicted.

Other charges can also be laid alongside, such as possession of stolen property and the use of forged documents.

In Ontario, provincial penalties for VIN fraud include fines of $50,000 to $100,000 and up to six months in jail, on top of any Criminal Code charges.⁸

What recourse do you have if you buy a reVINned car?

If you’ve fallen victim to VIN fraud, your recourse options will typically depend on where you bought the vehicle.

If you bought it from a dealership, provincial consumer protection legislation may compensate you for the loss. You’ll need to file a complaint with the respective regulator in your province, such as VSA in BC, OMVIC in Ontario, AMVIC in Alberta, or OPC in Quebec.

For private sales, your main avenue for recourse is to sue the seller directly. This can be complicated, and ideally you should talk to a lawyer as soon as possible about it. Have all your documentation ready, including the seller’s original advertisement, any text or email messages you had with the seller, the bill of sale, or anything else to support your claim that the seller perpetrated the fraud.

What measures are being taken to combat VIN fraud?

Many dealerships and manufacturers have started using advanced anti-cloning technologies to make it more difficult for criminals to alter the numbers. Etching VINs on the glass and other parts of the vehicle is one such example.⁹

At the government level, the Canadian Border Services Agency (CBSA) has begun sharing vehicle export data with organizations like CARFAX Canada and Équité Association. That data will be helpful for cracking down on fraudulent registrations, especially by criminals who use VINs from legally exported vehicles to reVIN stolen cars inside Canada.¹⁰

ServiceOntario has also introduced internal verification changes to close registration loopholes that were being exploited by organized crime.

Does car insurance cover VIN fraud?

No. Car insurance is meant to cover losses arising from accidents, theft, and other insured perils. If you buy a fraudulently misrepresented car (knowingly or unknowingly) and the police subsequently seize it, your insurer won’t compensate you for falling victim.

That said, always contact your insurer as soon as you suspect or confirm fraud. They’ll be able to help figure out your next steps, even if a payout isn’t on the table.

Sources

1. CARFAX Canada. “2025 Year in Rear View: CARFAX Canada Unveils Used Vehicle History Insights for the Year.” carfax.ca, 26 Nov. 2025, www.carfax.ca/media/carfax-canada-unveils-used-vehicle-history-insights-for-the-year-in-rear-view-2025.
2. Pearson, Mike. “Carfax is fighting back against auto theft with a VIN Fraud Check tool. Here’s how it works.” insidehalton.com, 14 Aug. 2025, www.insidehalton.com/news/auto-theft-fraud-carfax/article_9f0d1e9a-2521-53a1-8669-f49b9070e039.html. Accessed 30 Apr. 2026.
3. Woodward, Jon. “They Bought a Car from a Dealership but It Turned Out to Be Stolen. This Is How It Happened.” CTV News, 16 June 2025, www.ctvnews.ca/canada/article/they-bought-a-car-from-a-dealership-it-turned-out-to-be-stolen-how.
4. Raveendran, Rochelle. “Toronto police link ServiceOntario staff to fake VIN scheme as Ontario proposes penalties for auto fraud.” CBC News, 1 Nov. 2024, www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-government-vin-fraud-penalties-1.7370960.
5. Wilson, Jim. “Two Dealership Workers Arrested in Alleged Stolen Car Scam.” HRD Canada, 7 Nov. 2024, www.hcamag.com/ca/specialization/employment-law/two-dealership-workers-arrested-in-alleged-stolen-car-scam/513057.
6. Woodward, Jon. “A $1M Ferrari — or Is It? Insurance Investigators Face Rising Fraud Claims.” CTV News, 19 June 2025, www.ctvnews.ca/canada/article/a-1-million-ferrari-or-is-it-canadas-insurance-investigators-face-rising-fraud-claims.
7. Criminal Code. “R.S.C., 1985, c. C-46, s. 380 — Fraud.” laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/section-380.html. Accessed 30 Apr. 2026.
8. Government of Ontario. “Safer Streets, Stronger Communities Act, 2024.” ontario.ca, ontario.ca/laws/statute/s24027. Accessed 30 Apr. 2026.
9. “VIN Cloning — A Growing Concern in the Canadian Automotive Industry.” Insurance Business Canada, 23 May 2023, www.insurancebusinessmag.com/ca/news/auto-motor/vin-cloning–a-growing-concern-in-the-canadian-automotive-industry-446843.aspx.
10. Public Safety Canada. “National Action Plan on Combatting Auto Theft.” publicsafety.gc.ca, www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/cntrng-crm/autothft-cntrvhcls/ctn-pln-en.aspx. Accessed 30 Apr. 2026.

Want to learn more? Visit our vehicle owner resource centre for dozens of helpful articles. Or, get an online car insurance quote in under 5 minutes and find out how affordable personalized coverage can be.