Reviewed by Sunny Dhiman
Updated December 10, 2025 | Published December 10, 2025
New drivers pay more for car insurance — that’s no secret. But how much more? And why?
In this article, we explain how car insurance works for drivers with learner’s or novice licences, as well as young drivers who’ve earned their full licence. Plus, a look at insurance rates for these groups and why those rates are usually so high. And finally, how young drivers can reduce their car insurance rates.

The important points
New drivers need car insurance, just like anyone driving in Canada. But, they don’t necessarily need to buy their own policy.
For teenagers and other young drivers, it’s much more common to use a parent’s or guardian’s car insurance. It’s easy to add a child to one’s policy — just talk to your insurance provider (or make a policy change online). There’s usually no added premium for including a learner-level driver, though that may change once they earn their probationary licence and start driving alone.
It becomes a little more complicated if a learner driver owns their own car. Sometimes, they can include that car on their parents’ policy if everyone lives at the same address — but this depends on the provider.
Obviously, not all new drivers live with a parent from whom they can borrow a car and an insurance policy.
People with learner’s licences are sometimes restricted from buying their own policies. They may need to meet specific requirements, such as being the owner and main operator of their vehicle and being the only licensed driver in their household. At the very least, their rates will be high.
People with novice or probationary licences can usually buy their own policies as needed, though they too will likely see higher prices.
Most new drivers are also young, but there are people who wait until they’re older to get their driver’s licence.
A “new” driver is anyone who has their learner’s licence or novice license (like classes G1 or G2 in Ontario) or has just recently earned their full licence. A “young” driver is anyone under the age of about 25, regardless of their licence status.
Insurance providers look at licence status and age separately. A driver’s age mostly only affects the price, but the licence class can introduce some additional restrictions. For example, someone with a learner’s licence might find it harder to buy their own insurance regardless of their age.
Insurance providers consider a driver’s licence class and history separately from their age for underwriting and pricing purposes.
Once you’ve got yourself a driver’s licence and a car, it’s time to buy car insurance. Note that you do actually need to own a car; you don’t need to buy insurance to drive someone else’s car (assuming that car’s already insured).
Even for a first timer, the process is straightforward:
At minimum, you’ll need your driver’s licence number and vehicle details (make, model, year, and Vehicle Identification Number). You’ll also need to provide your home address.
If you have ever held a driver’s licence in a different province or country, you might need to provide documentation to show your driving history. After all, even a short period of being previously licensed could help you save on your new policy. You’ll need a driver’s abstract from each jurisdiction in which you previously held a licence. Note that many insurance providers only consider driving experience from Canada and the US.
Depending on which province you live in, you may or may not need to shop around for your insurance.
In BC, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba, you’ll be buying basic insurance from the public insurer, so it doesn’t matter too much where you go — the price and basic options won’t change. Some brokers offer their own features beyond the basic coverage, but the base policy is always the same.
In every other province and territory, you’ll buy from a private company. Don’t get overwhelmed — each province heavily regulates car insurance, and you’ll be buying the same base policy no matter where you go. The differences between providers are mainly:
So, to evaluate these differences, you can request car insurance quotes from several different providers. Getting a quote is basically buying a policy without the actual purchase step; you’ll give all the necessary information and make coverage selections, and the provider will give you a price.
Many providers offer online car insurance quotes that you can complete from your phone or computer. Square One’s online car insurance quotes can be as quick as five minutes. You can also do it over the phone with an agent. Some providers offer in-person service as well.
Based on the quotes you get, you can decide which you like best. Which has the best price? Are you getting similar coverage from each? Did you like the customer service?
Once you’ve decided, buying the policy will be easy. After all, you already completed most of the application to get the quote. Just follow the chosen provider’s instructions for purchasing your quoted policy. Much of the time, that’s it — provide some payment information and they’ll issue your policy documents and pink card (proof of insurance). If they offer electronic delivery, like Square One, you’ll receive these documents immediately via email.
Occasionally, they may need to request additional information after reviewing your application. If that’s the case, they’ll let you know.
Once you’ve got your proof of insurance, you’re ready to drive. Make sure you always have the pink card with you; driving without insurance is illegal, and you need to be able to demonstrate that you’re insured.
Many provinces and territories allow digital pink cards, meaning you can keep the proof on your phone. Just keep in mind that it’s wise to keep a paper backup, because having your phone die (or forgetting it) aren’t valid excuses.
ready for an online quote? Your time matters, and so does your car. Get a personalized car insurance quote in 5 minutes. That’s less time than it takes to wait in line for coffee. Car insurance is available in Ontario and Quebec.
Before you start, please review our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
The cost is pretty much everyone’s main concern with car insurance. Unfortunately for new and young drivers, car insurance usually costs them more than it does experienced drivers.
Insurance providers use dozens or hundreds of factors to calculate car insurance rates.
Among the most important factors are a driver’s experience level, insurance history, and claim history. New drivers pay more because they have little experience and no demonstrable history of safe driving. Even if a new driver is the most cautious, attentive driver on the road, they have no way to prove it. Plus, teenage drivers are statistically more likely to be involved in accidents than older drivers.1 Insurance pricing is based on risk, so this higher risk profile results in higher premiums.
Because insurance pricing is risk-based, new drivers typically pay more; their lack of experience and safe driving history make them riskier to insure.
Other factors are common to all drivers. Things like a person’s age, gender, location, vehicle type, commute distance, and even credit score can all have an effect, depending on the provider.
Luckily, there are a few ways new drivers can offset the higher prices.
The primary option for new drivers to reduce their premiums is to complete an accredited driver training course. Most insurance providers offer discounts for completing a valid program, including Square One (in Ontario). These discounts are not available in Quebec, where driver training is mandatory, thus it’s assumed that everyone’s done it.2
Like anyone else, new drivers can reduce their premiums by maintaining a clean driving record. As long as a new driver doesn’t get in any accidents or receive any speeding (or other) tickets, their insurance should start dropping each year (at least for a while).
New drivers also have the same tools as other drivers for modifying their policy to reduce their price, like raising deductibles or adjusting vehicle usage. Check out our tips for saving on car insurance for those details.
Because car insurance pricing is based on more than just a driver’s age and experience, the price varies a lot. But, for example, new drivers in Ontario pay anywhere from $3,000 to $6,000 annually ($250 to $500 monthly).3 In Quebec, drivers aged 16 to 20 pay an average of $929 annually ($77 monthly) for collision or upset coverage.
Although average prices for brand-new drivers are often high, they decrease year after year as long as the driver maintains a clean record — no speeding tickets, accidents, or similar incidents.
For example, here are average rates based on sample quotes obtained for theoretical driver profiles. The samples consisted of two 19-year-olds, two 22-year-olds, and two 24-year-olds, with a male and female driver for each age group. Each driver had a similar compact car that was a few years old, commuted 7 km, and drove approximately 15,000 km annually. The sample included quotes for different cities within each province.4
| Province | 19-year-olds | 22-year-olds | 24-year-olds |
| BC | $3,858 | $2,759 | $2,606 |
| Saskatchewan | $1,285 | $1,287 | $1,221 |
| Manitoba | $1,865 | $1,499 | $1,634 |
| Ontario | $4,499 | $3,070 | $2,547 |
This may be a small sample, but it illustrates how premiums for young drivers tend to decrease year after year. You can also see how much these prices vary by province.
Most drivers should expect their “young driver” status to end around age 25, depending on the provider. However, age remains a factor in determining the price. It’s just that the year-to-year change becomes smaller and is overshadowed by larger rating factors.
Sources
Want to learn more? Visit our Car insurance resource centre for dozens of helpful articles. Or, get an online car insurance quote in under 5 minutes and find out how affordable personalized coverage can be.
About the expert: Sunny Dhiman
Sunny has been with Square One since 2017, and presently holds the title of Call Centre Manager. Sunny is responsible for training and coaching new and exisiting employees. He also advises on complex underwriting, quote, or policy related matters. Sunny has a level 2 general insurance licence in BC, Alberta, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan. He has an OTL licence in Ontario and an AMF licence in Quebec. Sunny is also working on CAIB and CIP designations.
Check out these related articles:
Get a personalized online home insurance quote in just 5 minutes and see how much money you can save by switching to Square One.
Even when you take precautions, accidents can happen. Home insurance is one way to protect your family against financial losses from accidents. And, home insurance can start from as little as $15/month.